Furniture bankruptcy sale

Tuesday, November 29th, 2011

From Mom and Pop To Corporate Giant to Bankrupt


Let me tell you the story of a business that was founded over 50 years ago. They were a family furniture operation that had grown from a small mom and pop shop to an organization that operated three stores and did $10 million in sales. Times were good-for a while. Last year they declared bankruptcy and closed their doors.

by David McMahon, published by and for WHFA (Western Home Furnishings Association). Reposted with permission.

The slowing economy, as in many cases like this, was only one factor. In fact, in this case there was only a modest sales decline relative to similar businesses. The primary factor for their demise was an outright failure to be a student of their business.

Their family had grown so there were more people to support. Between the various brothers, sisters, sons, daughters, and cousins, there were multiple people who relied on the business to pay for their mortgages and feed their families. On top of this, there was no clear leader. Every decision had to go through a sort of unanimous voting process. This slowed their speed to react and innovate. And the decisions that were made were often times on issues that were not of any great benefit to the business. They wasted time. It got so bad that there was one argument amongst the brothers and sisters on who was supposed to put the toilet paper in the bathrooms! They had little time to focus on what counted. They only tracked written sales. All the other critical measures were ignored.

Eventually they decided to take on debt to finance their growing accounts payable. They tried mass event sales to blow out their inventory. They were just able to break even. They repeated this strategy of refinancing debt and big event sales. Eventually they became insolvent. This meant that they could not pay for their short term obligations. Minimal profitability, missing sales goals, and rising debt put the nail in their coffin. Bankrupt.

Unfortunately, stories like this are far too common. If this company had a leader and a team who knew what red flags to look for and took action soon enough, they would have survived. In this article I’m going to show you the red flags to look for. If you keep your eyes on these, you will greatly improve your chances of success and you will be able to take corrective measures sooner. With you as a decisive leader of your capable team, your cash flow potential can be maximized.

  • Sales to Plan.
    Sales drive everything. Your plan is your realistic projection of sales or your budget. It is also t dollar amount needed to produce your required profitability and cash flow. To calculate this, take your actual monthly sales and divide by monthly sales on your budget (your pro plan). For example, if sales were $550,000 and planned sales were $525,000, then sales to plan is 105 percent. This should be checked monthly, quarterly, and year-to-date each month Repeated under performance of sales to plan (under 100 percent) signifies either performance issues with sales or a budget that needs to be adjusted in its entirety.
  • Profitability.
    This is the ultimate source of all cash It is sales minus all your expenses. To view as a percent, divide that number by sales. No operation can operate with a loss for very long and few can operate at average profitability (2-4 percent) and grow their business. Alternatively, healthy profitability (7 percent+) enables growth through reinvestment of equity into the business. This investment leads to expansion and takes the form of technology, train capital investment, merchandise lines, and human talent. Paying out all the profit to shareholders does little for the future of business. It is important to note that profitability needs to be consistent to really make a difference. It should be checked each month on certifiably correct financials b for the month and year-to-date.
  • Quick Ratio.
    Also called the acid test ratio. It is a measure of the liquidity that you have in your business. It calculated by taking your current assets, less your inventor divided by your current liabilities. An even ratio of 1 is so Anything under .5 means your business may be in a dang area. Companies with very low quick ratios are at risk of insolvency.
  • Cash to Current Payables.
    This measures your ability to pay for your immediate responsibilities. It largely indicates whether you can honor your short term loans from your vendors. The importance of this is critical to continue uninterrupted flow of goods. Many companies in the last few years have shut their doors because their vend simply stopped shipping. Track this monthly and seek to b consistently above 25 percent. Anyone under 15 percent is probably struggling to make ends meet and are most likely dipping into lines of credit.
  • GMROI.
    Gross margin return on inventory. All your cash comes from selling inventory, right? And if you sell your inventory faster or carry less of it, you generate cash faster, right? That’s what GMROI is-the ultimate measure of your operations effectiveness at creating dollars! Figure this by annualizing your gross margin dollars and dividing by your average or current inventory on hand. Do it every month without fail. Seek to continually improve this number overall. I call a $2 GMROI a break-even GMROI and a $2.5+ GMROI an “in the money” GMROI.
  • Inventory to Sales.
    This flag is your key to controlling new buying. Purchasing should follow sales results or realistic forecasts. You all know what could happen if you go to market and you buy without a plan. Only a certain percent of the new merchandise sells; the rest sits in stagnation. Obviously, invoices become due for that inventory whether it sells or not. Timing and the amount you spend on new merchandise is everything. In fact, most of the businesses that have gone out in the last few years were overbought when the economy was good. That’s why they could not weather the storm. Figure your inventory to sales by taking your average or current inventory that is in your possession and divide it by your annualized sales. I’ve been in the analyzing and advising business for over a decade and have never seen a profitable and growing business operate consistently above 20 percent. I call 15-17 percent the “sweet spot”. Faster turning categories such as bedding or appliances can be even less. Only purchase new merchandise if inventory to sales is in the “sweet spot” range.
  • Gross Margin.
    How much money do you have left to pay for all operating costs and make a healthy profit after you deduct your cost of goods and freight from the sale of your merchandise? That is your gross margin. Figure as a percent each month and year-to-date by dividing by your sales. In retail furniture and bedding, most operations have two options, in my opinion: be above 46 percent or below 42 percent. The reason relates to sales volume and turns. There is just very little economies of scale with small and medium sized businesses. Fixed operating costs can eat profits unless the margin is appropriate. Unless you have a killer deal on rent and a great location, a store doing under $5 million will find it difficult to operate at under 46 percent margin on their financial statements. Alternatively, for example, a store with sales of over $20 million could operate at a lower margin and be a low cost seller and still be decently profitable. Below is profit matrix of where cash is typically made with respect to gross margin and turns. Avoid the “death zone”.
  • Operating Costs.
    These are all the costs that you incur each month after your cost of goods. You should set target percentages of sales by department in your master budget so that you can avoid expense profit erosion. The commonly tracked departments in your operating budget are: administration, occupancy, selling, marketing, service, warehouse, delivery, and finance. Overall high profit operations seek to be under 38 percent. Be a student of your business. Watch for the red flags. That is the first step on your road to achieving a healthier cash flow position. It is the first step in giving your business longevity whatever your sales volume is. It is difficult to improve what you don’t track so doing this will help. The next step is to take the right decisive actions at the right time. The slowing economy, as in many cases like this, was only one factor. In fact, in this case there was only a modest sales decline relative to similar businesses. The primary factor for their demise was an outright failure to be a student of their business.
Saturday, November 19th, 2011

Former PFP clients… Rosa’s Bounce Back After Bankruptcy (excerpt from “The Buffalo News”)


The three sons of the founder of the defunct Rosa’s Home Stores chain have opened stores selling furniture and bedding in two former Rosa’s locations in the Town of Tonawanda and Cheektowaga.
The sons, with the support of their father, opened Home Furniture Gallery outlets late last month on Sheridan Drive and this month on Union Road. The sons all held positions with Rosa’s Home Stores, which left more than 1,000 creditors when it filed for bankruptcy last December, but the Rosas say Home Furniture Gallery is an entirely separate enterprise. “It’s a brand-new business — it’s brand new,” said Paul F. Rosa, the founder of Rosa’s Home Stores who serves as chairman of Home Furniture Gallery.
The new stores promote a 30-day, money-back guarantee and offer customers the transparent choice of different levels of quality at a range of prices.
One main distinction between the old and new stores is Home Furniture Gallery isn’t selling electronics or appliances.
“There’s unprecedented pressure on profit margins for both appliances as well as consumer electronics,” said Burt P. Flickinger III, a Buffalo native and managing director of Strategic Resource Group, the retail consulting firm. Sons Paul M., David and Anthony Rosa say they are confident they can take on the local and national chains in what is a highly competitive furniture and bedding market.
They have opted not to use the Rosa’s name on the company, or in its advertising, but analysts believe their experience and reputation only can help them.
“They have a proven track record as a retailer,” said Michael C. Clark, CB Richard Ellis’ director of retail tenant services. The Home Furniture Gallery stores opened in former Rosa’s locations at 2880 Sheridan Drive, at Eggert Road, and at 3770 Union Road, near the Walden Galleria. David Rosa said the brothers oversaw modest renovations to the two stores, including knocking down some walls, putting on a fresh coat of paint and cleaning the carpets. The brothers all are vice presidents, with David serving as chief financial officer, Paul M. responsible for operations and Anthony overseeing sales.
Once they fill a few remaining open positions, the company will employ 50 workers, including a number who worked for Rosa’s Home Stores.
Friday, December 24th, 2010

Planned Furniture Promotions approved to liquidate Rosa’s Home Stores



Planned Furniture Promotions Honors Customer Deposits

 Buffalo, NY, December 23, 2010 –-  Rosa’s Home Store, a leading home furnishings appliance and electronics retailer operating four stores in Western New York since 1981, filed for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy protection on December 9, 2010 in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of New York.  As a result of Tuesday’s bankruptcy hearing, the company will begin Going-Out-Of-Business/Bankruptcy Liquidation sales managed by the foremost furniture event company, Planned Furniture Promotions, Inc.

All customer deposits made prior to the Chapter 11 filing will be honored. “This was the most important aspect of the bankruptcy filing”, said Dean Rallo, president, Rosa Home Store. “Rosa’s didn’t want this bankruptcy to negatively impact our loyal customers, so we worked very closely with our legal team and the bankruptcy court to put our customers first.” Store customers with open orders will receive instructions for completing their orders.   

 “We’re proud to have been chosen by Rosa’s, an institution in the community, to assist the company in this difficult time,” said Tom Liddell, senior vice president of Planned Furniture Promotions. “We look forward to assisting Rosa’s complete the many customer orders that were placed prior to the Bankruptcy filing and conducting a sale that  will benefit the company, its vendors and creditors, and many local customers.”

Rosa’s Home Store operates three locations in Buffalo and one store in Niagara Falls, a region of the country that has been in economic decline for three decades.    The stores will be closed for a short period, to complete an inventory and prepare for the liquidation, followed by the public sale early next year.

Tuesday, April 27th, 2010

Arnold’s Furniture


It was very sad for a downtown 52 year old business to close but we have, with your help, accomplished this with dignity and good repute and I will always be appreciative of your company and staff. We could have never done this by ourselves.

Arnold’s Furniture
Tullahoma, TN
Patricia Mathis, President

Tuesday, April 27th, 2010

Hoover’s Furniture


Customer service right to the very end. Our legacy is intact, and we thank you, Planned Furniture Promotions.

Now we are left with our buildings broom-clean, our integrity intact, and no added stress at the end of an era. We want to thank David Cosenza, Sr. and the PFP team for a job well done with the utmost integrity and professionalism.

Hoover’s Furniture
Lexington, KY
AF Dawahare, President

Tuesday, April 27th, 2010

AA Mooney Company


It was extremely important to me that my staff who had worked very hard for me for many years he included and taken care of during this sale. This was done very effectively and my people became part of the PFP team. This was probably the most gratifying part of the sale and as important to me as the success of the sale.

AA Mooney Company
Bedford, NH
Mark E. Reingold, President

Tuesday, April 27th, 2010

Hitchcock Fine Home Furnishings


It was an extremely difficult decision to close the Hitchcock stores. At nearly 200 years, Hitchcock is one of the oldest brands in the industry. As you know, because we intend to sell the brand after the sale of the furniture it was very important for us to protect our Intellectual Property and not damage the integrity of the brand during this event.

We did extensive due diligence in evaluating the firms that could represent Hitchcock during the most important sale of our company. I am glad that we selected PFP, and I am proud of the way PFP treated our employees, our customers and our brand. Hitchcock has employees with over 40 years of service and customers whose parents and grandparents own our products. Everyone, employees, customers and owners were happy with the results.

Hitchcock Fine Home Furnishings
New Hartford, CT
Ronald Coleman, President

Saturday, April 17th, 2010

Endorsement Letters


Our Clients Share Their Own Success Stories

PFP has successfully served a broad spectrum of stores, large and small.

Click each logo to read their stories, in their own words.

Lipkin Furniture
Moore Furniture Propper Brothers Comfort Furniture

You’ve read what our clients have to say about PFP now you can listen to them. Click Here.